Comparative Effectiveness of Cephalexin Plus Trimethoprim-Sulfamethoxazole Versus Cephalexin Alone for Treatment of Uncomplicated Cellulitis: A Randomized Controlled Trial
|
Design |
Randomized, multicenter, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial
N= 153
|
Objective |
To test the hypothesis that antibiotics targeting community-acquired methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (CA-MRSA) are beneficial in the treatment of cellulitis
|
Study Groups |
Trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole (TMP/SMX; n= 73)
Placebo (n= 73)
|
Inclusion Criteria |
Must have cellulitis as defined by recent onset of soft tissue erythema or color change, considered bacterial in origin, with signs of infection; agreement from clinical attending physician for treatment with cephalexin; patient understanding and consent; commitment to follow-up appointments
|
Exclusion Criteria |
Age <12 months or weight <15 kg, current skin infection already treated, allergy to sulfa drugs, severe allergic reaction to penicillin, current use of any antibiotic, diabetes mellitus, cellulitis complicated by peripheral vascular disease, renal insufficiency, hospital admission required, purulent discharge >1 cc, cellulitis involving indwelling catheter, immunocompromise, pregnancy, breastfeeding, facial cellulitis, cellulitis associated with marine or freshwater injury or animal/human bite, history of glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase deficiency, taking certain medications, known megaloblastic anemia due to folate deficiency
|
Methods |
Participants received cephalexin and were randomized to receive either trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole (TMP-SMX) or placebo. Antibiotics were provided for 14 days, with instructions to continue for at least 1 week and stop 3 days after feeling cured. Main outcome was treatment success at 2 weeks, confirmed at 1 month.
The following dosing scheme was used for cephalexin and trimethoprim-sulfmethoxazole (based on mg trimethoprim):
Children <30 kg
15-19 kg: cephalexin 300 mg 4 times daily; TMP-SMX 40/200 mg 4 times daily
20-24 kg: cephalexin 400 mg 4 times daily; TMP-SMX 60/300 mg 4 times daily
25-29 kg: cephalexin 500 mg 4 times daily; TMP-SMX 72/360 mg 4 times daily
Adults and children ≥30 kg:
<60 kg: cephalexin 500 mg 4 times daily; TMP-SMX 80/400 mg 4 times daily
60-80 kg: cephalexin 1,000 mg 3 times daily; TMP-SMX 160/800 mg 3 times daily
>80 kg: cephalexin 1,000 mg 4 times daily; TMP-SMX 160/800 mg 4 times daily
|
Duration |
June 2007 to December 2011
|
Outcome Measures |
Primary: Risk difference for treatment success
Secondary: Association of nasal MRSA colonization with treatment response
|
Baseline Characteristics |
|
All Participants (N = 146) |
Trimethoprim-Sulfamethoxazole (n= 73) |
Placebo (n= 73) |
Age (median [range, interquartile range]) |
29 (3–74, 23–43) |
31 (12–71, 25–47) |
27 (3–74, 22–40) |
Race - White |
88 (60) |
44 (60) |
44 (60) |
Race - Black |
24 (16) |
13 (18) |
11 (15) |
Race - Asian |
3 (2) |
1 (1.4) |
2 (2.7) |
Race - Other |
1 (0.68) |
0 (0) |
1 (1.4) |
Hispanic |
38 (26) |
19 (26) |
19 (26) |
Antibiotics in the past year |
57 (39) |
24 (33) |
33 (45) |
Past history of skin infection |
50 (34) |
25 (34) |
25 (34) |
Ever diagnosed with MRSA |
3 (2.1) |
2 (2.7) |
1 (1.4) |
Physical contact with someone with MRSA |
17 (12) |
10 (14) |
7 (9.7) |
Nasal MRSA colonization |
7 (4.9) |
4 (5.6) |
3 (4.2) |
Infection Characteristics - Purulence |
19 (13) |
8 (11) |
11 (15) |
Infection Characteristics - Warmth |
136 (94) |
69 (96) |
67 (92) |
Infection Characteristics - Fever |
19 (13) |
9 (12) |
10 (14) |
Infection Characteristics - Lymphangitis |
16 (12) |
8 (13) |
8 (12) |
Infection Characteristics - Induration |
65 (46) |
33 (47) |
32 (44) |
Infection Characteristics - Ulceration |
18 (13) |
11 (15) |
7 (10) |
Infection Characteristics - Pain |
138 (95) |
69 (95) |
69 (95) |
Infection Characteristics - Edema |
106 (74) |
58 (81) |
48 (68) |
Varying Events - Received up to 24 h of intravenous therapy |
40 (27) |
18 (25) |
22 (30) |
Results |
|
Trimethoprim-Sulfamethoxazole (n= 73) |
Placebo (n= 73) |
Risk Difference (95% CI) |
p-value |
Cure (no failure by final follow-up at 30 d) (%) |
62 (85) |
60 (82) |
2.7 (−9.3% to 15%) |
.66 |
Progression to abscess (%) |
5 (6.8) |
5 (6.8) |
0 (−8.2% to 8.2%) |
1.0 |
Any adverse event (%) |
36 (49) |
39 (53) |
−4.1 (−20% to 12%) |
.62 |
Diarrhea (%) |
21 (29) |
25 (34) |
−5.5 (−21% to 10%) |
.48 |
Nausea (%) |
15 (21) |
13 (18) |
2.7 (−10% to 16%) |
.67 |
Vomiting (%) |
5 (6.9) |
8 (11) |
−4.1 (−13% to 5.1%) |
.38 |
Rash (%) |
4 (5.5) |
3 (4.1) |
1.4 (−5.6% to 8.3%) |
.70 |
Pruritus (%) |
5 (6.9) |
3 (4.1) |
2.7 (−4.6% to 10%) |
.47 |
Candidiasis (%) |
1 (1.4) |
3 (4.1) |
−2.7 (−8.0% to 2.5%) |
.31 |
Clostridium difficile colitis (%) |
0 (0) |
1 (1.4) |
−1.4 (−4.0% to 1.3%) |
.32 |
Other adverse events (%)
|
3 (4.1) |
3 (4.1) |
0 (−6.4% to 6.4%) |
1.0 |
CI, confidence interval
|
Adverse Events |
Any adverse event: 49% in trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole group vs 53% in placebo group. Common adverse events included diarrhea, nausea, vomiting, rash, pruritus, candidiasis, and Clostridium difficile colitis |
Study Author Conclusions |
The addition of trimethoprim-sulfamethoxazole to cephalexin did not improve outcomes in the treatment of cellulitis without abscess. This supports IDSA guidelines against targeting CA-MRSA for nonpurulent cellulitis
|
Critique |
The study provides valuable experimental evidence supporting IDSA guidelines, but its limitations include the inability to make an etiologic diagnosis of cellulitis and its restriction to outpatient settings. The study's modest size and exclusion of certain patient populations, such as those with complicated skin infections, limit its generalizability. |